Sean Maloughney: Is a Guentzel Trade Feasible?

Sean Maloughney: Is a Guentzel Trade Feasible?
- freelancer

too bad the oilers have very little to offer in a trade for the below package.

Hart 3.9
TK 2.75 (50% retained)
Sean Walker 1.3 (50% retained)

How about chasing an upgrade on defense or depth in net.

too bad the oilers have very little to offer in a trade for the below package.

Hart 3.9
TK 2.75 (50% retained)
Sean Walker 1.3 (50% retained)
- hello it's me 2050

So Pitt is rolling with Jarry and Hart? Seems a bit odd

How about chasing an upgrade on defense or depth in net.
- Reveen

As always, it's about out-scoring our weakness

So Pitt is rolling with Jarry and Hart? Seems a bit odd
- nanook82

what does pitt have to do with my proposed package to the oilers?

Trade Bouchard for him.

How about chasing an upgrade on defense or depth in net.
- Reveen

Why start now?

Pens would want youth not an old BAT like Kane How dumb to even think that Pit would be on the hook for 50% You are just a dumb arse

Guentzel is American. Not sure he would extend in EDM. Regardless, Dubas is very unlikely to trade Guentzel unless he clearly isn't re-signing AND if PIT is well out of a playoff spot. If they stay within striking distance like they are now and have been for almost the entire season, they're not selling. I also agree with most other comments that Holland should be bolstering RD or G positions before he considers W.

Trade Bouchard for him.
- K-man25

Ironically, that is a poor trade for both teams. PIT has Letang and Karlsson at RD and EDM needs Bouchard a lot more than they need Guentzel.

Ironically, that is a poor trade for both teams. PIT has Letang and Karlsson at RD and EDM needs Bouchard a lot more than they need Guentzel.
- jfkst1

It’s was in reference to the outscoring your shortcomings.

I really don't think any huge changes are needed. This team finished last season 15-1 and are currently 14-3. Teams don't go on streaks like that unless they are elite.

Sure, if a trade comes along that really helps then go for it or tinker here and there but don't sell the farm thinking we have to do something. Guentzel would be great but at the same time I like having players like Kane during the playoffs.

This place is better with Turd takes.

I really don't think any huge changes are needed. This team finished last season 15-1 and are currently 14-3. Teams don't go on streaks like that unless are elite.

Sure, if a trade comes along that really helps then go for it or tinker here and there but don't sell the farm thinking we have to do something. Guentzel would be great but at the same time I like having players like Kane during the playoffs.
- Oildrum

Best team in the league currently not in a playoff position, that’s elite enough for some.

I really don't think any huge changes are needed. This team finished last season 15-1 and are currently 14-3. Teams don't go on streaks like that unless they are elite.

Sure, if a trade comes along that really helps then go for it or tinker here and there but don't sell the farm thinking we have to do something. Guentzel would be great but at the same time I like having players like Kane during the playoffs.
- Oildrum

Very much like the Canucks EDM is a few players away from making any real noise in the PO's. Need another top forward and a Dman for the PO's. Losing Bjugstad, Kostin and Yamamoto really hurt you at first but the Oil appear to be over it. See where it goes.

what does pitt have to do with my proposed package to the oilers?
- hello it's me 2050

Yup, read your original post wrong. My bad, I get it now haha

Best team in the league currently not in a playoff position, that’s elite enough for some.

- K-man25

Oil are coming. Inevitable.

Holy Shesterkin!

Guentzel is NOT what this team needs!!! Will the Oilers (and fans) never learn???
Trading away Kane is ridiculous! One if the only guys on the squad who consistently plays with passion. Or one of the other only guys? Foegle!
I mean...who comes up with this nonsense?

The team needs good old fashioned "heart" and "grind"...not yet another forward who's pretty good offensively.

Bouchard, Broberg, Draisaitl, hell...even Nuge these days...they don't seem to want to work hard. THOSE are the guys to be shopped, not the workhorses.

Get a 2way forward, a warrior beast 1st pairing D, and a damned goalie. Not Guentzel?!?! Seriously, wtf?

Holy Shesterkin!

Guentzel is NOT what this team needs!!! Will the Oilers (and fans) never learn???
Trading away Kane is ridiculous! One if the only guys on the squad who consistently plays with passion. Or one of the other only guys? Foegle!
I mean...who comes up with this nonsense?

The team needs good old fashioned "heart" and "grind"...not yet another forward who's pretty good offensively.

Bouchard, Broberg, Draisaitl, hell...even Nuge these days...they don't seem to want to work hard. THOSE are the guys to be shopped, not the workhorses.

Get a 2way forward, a warrior beast 1st pairing D, and a damned goalie. Not Guentzel?!?! Seriously, wtf?
- JLO961

Good luck with that.

No excuse not to win this one tonight.

15-3 now last 18.

15-3 now last 18.
- Oildrum

What was their record the first 18 games?
Peeking at the right time.

Hart - 1.989 (50% retention)
Walker -1.675 (50% retention)
Seeler - 775

for

?
?
?

What was their record the first 18 games?
Peeking at the right time.
- K-man25

You guys are playing 2 matinees in a row